Pet Sitting in Shelter Island

Pet sitters in Shelter Island, New York who will care for your furry friend at home without any charges!

When do you need a pet sitter?

How it works?

video thumbnail

There are 6,652 pet sitters near you

Sitter Profile Image: Brooke
Brooke

Shelter Island, New York

Experienced & personable Petsitter available

5.0
• 29 reviews
Owner Image

If I could give more than 5 stars, I would! Brooke and Kirk took excellent care of our elderly cat, and they left our house in pristine condition. Brooke sent daily texts, and it was clear that our cat felt at ease with them. We welcome Brooke and Kirk back anytime!

Sitter available from Oct 1
Verify availability
Sitter Profile Image: Stephanie
Stephanie

Shelter Island, New York

Trustworthy and Compassionate Housesitter.

5.0
• 23 reviews
Owner Image

This was Stephanie’s second time sitting for Hannah and Henry and these two shy kitties clearly remembered her and are very comfortable having her visit. Henry is a little less shy and cozies right up to her! It is so reassuring to leave them in such great hands!

Sitter available from Oct 1
Verify availability
Sitter Profile Image: Michelle
Michelle

Shelter Island, New York

Responsible and Compassionate Pet & House Care that Goes Above and Beyond

5.0
• 17 reviews
Owner Image

Such a wonderful experience having Michelle and Ryan take care of our babies. They were very communicative and clear starting from our first call - we got lots of photo updates and they let us know as soon as any issues cropped up (we had some minor ant invasions as the summer heat kicked in which they helped keep at bay). They were completely reliable and we came home to very chill cats so it was clear they got a lot of love. I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for pet sitting!

Sitter available from Oct 1
Verify availability
Sitter Profile Image: Hope
Hope

Shelter Island, New York

Responsible Traveling Couple Who Love Animals

5.0
• 16 reviews
Owner Image

Hope and Gerald did a great job taking care of the cats and our home. Hope was great with communication, sending pics of the cats often. She managed the small things that came up, and texted about any bigger questions. She left the house extremely tidy and even washed the sheets!! Would absolutely have her back if she ever wanted. Thanks!

Sitter available from Oct 1
Verify availability
Sitter Profile Image: Lisa
Lisa

Shelter Island, New York

Pick us! Retired, caring couple - we will love your pets and respect your home.

5.0
• 14 reviews
Owner Image

This is the second sit that Lisa and Jim did for us, so that tells you right away that we liked them enough to ask them back! They are a fun and personable couple whose company we have enjoyed. They stay in regular contact with pictures, and upon our return home the cat is healthy and happy, the house is clean, and they even left a lovely meal for us, truly over and above. We highly recommend Lisa and Jim as pet sitters.

Sitter available from Oct 1
Verify availability
Sitter Profile Image: Donna
Donna

Shelter Island, New York

Professional Couple-we will take great care of your best friend(s)and your home!

5.0
• 12 reviews
Owner Image

Donna and Eric were perfect petsitters in every way: We came home to a happy cat and a cleaner house than we left it. They sent wonderful photos daily of our cat who was clearly enjoying himself! They also left us a delicious coffee cake from their local bakery which was an added bonus. Highly recommend!

Sitter available from Oct 1
Verify availability
Sitter Profile Image: Elizabeth
Elizabeth

Shelter Island, New York

Mature, Responsible, Solo Female Traveler, Patient, Furry Feline Friend

5.0
• 11 reviews
Owner Image

I thought I had written a review but perhaps it got lost…… I can’t say enough wonderful things about Libby. She sent photos of Dexter daily and for the photos they had bonded. She was immaculate. When I came home the house was neater than when I left it. She is a wonderful sitter and I highly recommend her. I even found a plate of cookies she left for me.

Sitter available from Oct 1
Verify availability
Sitter Profile Image: SuEllen
SuEllen

Shelter Island, New York

Mature, dependable, loving sitter available to care for your home and pets.

5.0
• 10 reviews
Owner Image

Suellen was an awesome house sitter and pet sitter who went above and beyond. We were overseas and had a water issue at our house. SuEllen contacted us immediately and handled the situation with the water company, including forwarding us a video showing the issue and the explanation from the water company of what was going on. SuEllen was reliable and easy to communicate with. She left the house clean and tidy, and we had a happy cat when we returned. I would recommend SuEllen to anyone who needs a sitter. Thanks SuEllen for doing such a great job taking care of everything while we were away!

Sitter available from Oct 1
Verify availability
Sitter Profile Image: Lisa
Lisa

Shelter Island, New York

Kind, responsible retired librarian, traveler, serial crafter. Nice!

5.0
• 10 reviews
Owner Image

I had a great experience with Lisa. She was very communicative ahead of the sit and took great care of my pup. Thank you Lisa!

Sitter available from Oct 1
Verify availability
Sitter Profile Image: Marie
Marie

Shelter Island, New York

Paws & plants- quiet and responsible house sitter

4.77
• 22 reviews
Owner Image

Marie was a great sitter. She came by just before I left so I could show her around and where the kitty stuff was. She informed me on how the cats were doing during the sit. the Apartment was in great condition when I returned. Cats did notice me coming home, but I could tell they had not wanted for attention from Marie. I recommend her for any sit you have coming up.

Sitter available from Oct 1
Verify availability

Reviews from Pet Owners

4.93
253,301 reviews
4.93
253,301 reviews
4.96 Organised 4.96 Reliable 4.95 Clean and tidy 4.97 Self-sufficient 4.91 Pet care
User
Jennifer
Natalie and Christian were dream pet sitters while we were out of the country for 2.5 weeks. From start to finish, they were reliable and professional, with excellent communication. They had took great care of our dog and chickens and left the house and car in great shape. Plus, they’re just a really sweet young couple. We’d highly recommend them as house sitters.
User
Allison
Once again, having AnnaMarie take care of our pups was absolutely the right choice!! Her frequent updates, care of our house and fur babies was stellar! Although the dogs were thrilled to see us when we returned, as we chatted with Annemarie, we could see them continuing to go to her for affection and cuddles. It was so sweet to watch our one-year-old lick her ear and Annamarie just giggled and happily tolerated it. What a great sport😎. We would highly recommend her to anyone and would also suggest if you happen to see a less than perfect review for her ( there is only 1)I know the true story... it's unfortunate that some people are so unappreciative of someone who will go out of their way to care for their home and Pets (at no charge🙃🙃)-- it just boggles my mind and am confident they are not being honest!  Suffice it to say she is a gem and perfect sitter in every way- if you can get a chance to book with her- do not hesitate! We truly think of her as part of our family now and all 5 of our pups would agree!
User
Kim
We were lucky to have Andrea back for another sit with our elderly dog and feral cat. She has been wonderful both in the past and on this last sit for a month! We trust her implicitly and are always at ease that our pets will have the most kind and careful attention. 
She is excellent with videos and communication and very clean and tidy. 
Again we feel lucky to have found her, and feel she would be a great sitter for any pets!
User
Brooke
Sharon was a fantastic sitter for our week away! She left the house as tidy and clean as we left it, including changing the sheets for our arrival. I truly cannot even tell she was here and that made coming home after a long travel day so much easier.

She was communicative every step of the way and provided daily updates on our cat with photos. We knew our home and pet were in good hands! I would gladly welcome Sharon back any time should we be so lucky : )
User
Kate
Lindsay and Bryce provided excellent care to our two cats while we were gone. They are great communicators, took amazing care of our apartment and send regular updates and photos so that we knew all was going well. We would absolutely recommend them as responsible and thoughtful pet sitters who can be entrusted with the care of your home and pets.
User
Kathryn
Linda was an awesome pet sitter for my doggie Brodie! She gave him so much loving attention… he has some separation anxiety at 9 years old & she never left his side! She was so attentive to him & I am very grateful for that!

Linda’s communication was also something I liked… we texted & chatted on the phone before her arrival & I felt very comfortable with her being in my home & with my dog.
I could tell her number one reason to pet sit was her love for dogs & desire to be a wonderful companion for Brodie while I was away for the weekend!
Would love to have her back anytime…
User
Simon
BriAnna was our first pet sitter and we loved her :). She made every step very simple for us, communication was great, Pastis and Anubis seemed to be very happy with her, and the house was very clean when we came back. We highly recommend BriAnna to take care of your pets and we would love to have her back!
User
Molly
Kelly took excellent care of my cats, Bertie and Jewel. She reported that nervous and shy Jewel even licked her hand! She sent occasional photos and updates about the cats, which I really appreciated, and she emailed/texted me when there were questions. At the end of her stay, Kelly and I had a conversation that was helpful to me, as this was my first zeewoi experience, and I'm still learning how to best welcome sitters to my cats and house. She gave me some excellent ideas about how to streamline the "welcome guide" I leave for folks. I really appreciate her insight as an experienced pet- and house-sitter. It's reassuring to know that she places a priority on pet health and happiness!
User
Shelley
Absolutely Incredible....
I will not lie, I was hesitant because David did not have any pet sits before this one (gotta start somewhere) but because he did the background check I decided to contact him. We had a great phone conversation and the decision was made. He came to my house the night before I was leaving to learn all the ins and outs of taking care of my fur babies and then put himself up in a hotel for the night before the sit date. The next day he came over in the morning to learn a few more details before I left. I could not have chosen a better house sitter for my 2nd house sit . David communicated with me daily, sent pictures and we spoke via facetime. My little guy was feeling sick when David started and with diligence, love and kindness he was able to get my little guy eating again and feeling better. I would invite David back into my home over and over again but I am pretty sure he is going to be in high demand. Thank you David for everything!
User
Wanda
What an amazing couple we had as pet sitters for our two dogs!
You can truly feel their love for animals.  
Nancy sent pictures a couple of times letting us know that they were having fun also with our Cody and Carson!
Our home was perfect when we got home.  They even left a beautiful potted flower and card on our island in our kitchen.
We highly recommend this couple!
                              Jim & Wanda

House Sitting FAQs

Pet sitters on Zeewoi offer pet sitting free of charge.

The main reasons pet sitters join Zeewoi are:
- They can't have their own pet right now but want to share their love for animals by helping out locally.
- They are work from home professionalist and want to pet sit in different cities.
- Many retired teachers, nurses, firefighters, and others enjoy traveling and caring for pet on Zeewoi.

As of Aug 2024, there are 1,387 pet sitters in Shelter Island, New York .
You can filter, sort, expand your radius to find the perfect pet sitter near me.
As a reminder, pet sitters joining Zeewoi must pass a background check for you and your pet safety.

Zeewoi makes it easy to reach out to multiple pet sitters about your booking.
Typically, 94% of Shelter Island, New York pet sitters respond within 24 hours.
Once you create your profile, pet sitters can apply to care for your pets, and you can also invite them!

Yes! pet sitters joining Zeewoi must pass a background check before offering their services.